Ministry of Education apologises to Canterbury schools after scathing Ombudsman report

Comments Off on Ministry of Education apologises to Canterbury schools after scathing Ombudsman report 120

A scathing Ombudsman record has slammed the Ministry of Education for its managing of Canterbury school mergers and closures after the 2011 earthquakes.

The file, launched on Wednesday, observed great flaws inside the way the ministry engaged with faculty communities and endorsed it work with the education quarter to develop a system for final or merging colleges in future.

Principals and political figures were calling for the ministry and ex-Education Minister Hekia Parata to apologise over how Canterbury’s schools’ shake-up changed into dealt with. No apologies had been supplied till Wednesday, however the ministry had previously conceded it did not get the manner proper.

The Education Ministry has apologised after a essential report from the Chief Ombudsman said the ministry did not fully inform Christchurch faculties earlier than revealing plans in 2012 to shut and merge 38 of them following the Christchurch earthquake.
The Ombudsman’s file recommends the ministry work with the schooling area to develop procedure for final or merging character faculties or corporations of faculties. (Wainoni college, file picture)

At the assertion, principals have been given colored tags to wear on their chests. They later learned the colours represented their faculty’s destiny.

Chief Ombudsman Peter Boshier stated while ministry body of workers faced “remarkable challenges” in reorganising Canterbury colleges following the earthquakes, there has been a fundamental lack of transparency in its technique and schools had been left feeling “blindsided”.

“Essentially, while colleges and groups had been accomplishing what they notion changed into a proper dialogue about large destiny visions for education in Canterbury, the ministry turned into progressing a commercial enterprise case with unique plans for individual schools.”

A Christchurch Primary Principals’ Association inquiry into the schools’ shake-up made similar findings in 2016.
Ministry chief government Iona Holsted the dimensions of damage and disruption to faculties intended it was an “excellent situation” and, while the ministry’s intentions had been appropriate, she recounted it have to have done a higher job.

“They deserved higher. We allow them to down and we’re sorry. We recognize this undermined agree with and self-assurance in us, as the Ombudsman’s faculty closures report confirms.

“We didn’t got down to mislead or to keep human beings in the darkish, however the end result changed into that we weren’t as transparent as we should had been.”

Holsted said the ministry had performed plenty of work to position matters proper for the reason that initial declaration.

“We now interact with schools earlier in the manner and provide them with the statistics they want as early as we will.”

New Zealand Education Institute (NZEI) president Lynda Stuart said the file pondered what the situation was for communities and colleges at the time.

“I assume that sadness, that harm, that soul wound for lots of the ones schools and their communities at that point became virtually pointless.”

NZEI had warned the ministry to pay attention to children and principals approximately what they wished, but they had been “run roughshod over in the rush to finish the apparently pre-determined plans”, she said.

Green Party schooling spokeswoman Catherine Delahunty said the ministry had to sit down with the schools affected by the procedure and ask them what the results were.

She stated she did not understand whether all of the mergers had benefited college students.


The foremost of 1 Christchurch faculty close down after the town’s schooling shake-up in 2012 says he hopes the “mistaken method” will never be repeated.

To date, 9 Christchurch colleges have closed, such as Linwood Intermediate, Richmond School, Greenpark School and Manning Intermediate.

Fifteen others have merged into six. This year, Aranui High, Aranui School, Avondale School and Wainoni School became Haeata Community Campus. Central New Brighton School, North New Brighton School, and Freeville School have become Rawhiti School in 2016.

Phillipstown School, which merged with Woolston School to shape Te Waka Unua School in 2015, fought hard to avoid the merger.

Despite protests, a 550-signature petition, and 18 months of legal battles which went to the High Court, the merger changed into pressured thru.

Former Philipstown School primary Tony Simpson stated the Ombudsman’s findings, released on Wednesday, gave him a “feeling of hope that this can in no way be repeated once more”.

“The destruction of communities, the destruction and misery and disruption prompted to human beings’s lives, specifically children, mother and father, instructors, network organizations . . . Simply so many humans have been affected by this mistaken procedure.”

He stated he hoped neighborhood groups could play a “substantial part” in destiny selection-making about nearby schooling.

Halswell Primary School important Bruce Topham said the ministry’s apology was “lengthy overdue”.

“Some of these communities had been small and quite fragile, and some of them had been suffering due to the earthquakes, so for them it turned into like a double-whammy.”

Topham attended the closure declaration in 2012.

“There was an entire lot of grown-united states of americacrying, now not for their personal loss however due to the fact they felt they’d allow their network down,” he said.

“That changed into horrendous, it didn’t want to be like that.”

– There have been widespread gaps and flaws in the ministry’s engagement and verbal exchange with schools and communities.
– The mismanaged technique caused further strain to already traumatised groups, inflicting a primary loss of consider among the ministry and colleges.
– There became a essential lack of transparency inside the ministry’s method.
– The September 2012 declaration was poorly handled.

– The ministry publish a written apology in The Press newspaper to the colleges and communities affected.
– The ministry work with training leaders to develop a robust process for future engagement on school closures and mergers.
Ministry Leader government Iona Holsted the size of harm and disruption to faculties intended it was an “notable scenario” and, even as the ministry’s intentions were proper, she mentioned it must have carried out a better process.

“They deserved higher. We allow them to down and we’re sorry. We recognize this undermined accept as true with and confidence in us, as the Ombudsman’s college closures document confirms.


Geneva A. Crawford

View all contributions by Geneva A. Crawford

About Us

Latest tech world updates and news form all around the world at

Subscribe Us